Not to start a huge debate, but just want to point out some pertinent facts of the new regs. that went into effect 6/11/11.
They can be found: Here
It's pretty clear in several portions of "3541 Atlantic Sharks" that it is illegal to remove a prohibited species, ie: Sand Tiger from the water.
2.1 It shall be unlawful for any hook and line fisherman to remove from the water sandbar shark, or any other species of shark when prohibited from harvest under §3541.
There is no provision for "keeping them close to the water" or "having them out of the water for a minimal time".
And then there is:
6.0 It shall be unlawful to release any shark in the management unit or any sandbar shark in a manner that will not ensure said sharks maximum probability of survival. All species of shark when prohibited from harvest under §3541 must be immediately released.
No provision for taking pictures with the "crew", etc.
Like I said, not trying start a big thing, but do want to make sure everyone understands the laws.
Some are of the opinion that the way the law is written, the angler should go into the water with the shark to disengage the hook.
Maybe as a way to discourage the pursuit of these species.